Educational Resources

Pre-Trial Preparation in Family Court: Navigating the Path to Your Court Date (Part 1)

Written by Russell Alexander / (905) 655-6335

For those navigating the complexities of separation and divorce, the thought of going to trial can be daunting. Most family law cases settle outside of court, but some require a trial for resolution. This guide, the first in our series, demystifies the pre-trial process. It provides a comprehensive roadmap for preparing for trial, focusing on the trial record, financial statements, and the strategic use of offers to settle.

Compiling the Trial Record: Your Case in Documents

Understanding the Trial Record: The trial record is a compilation of documents that forms the foundation of your case, presenting your narrative through evidence and legal paperwork. It is crucial for telling your story to the judge and framing your arguments.

Essential Components: Rule 23(1) of the Family Law Rules mandates that the trial record must include specific documents such as the application and answer documents, any relevant court orders and endorsements, and the completed Trial Scheduling Endorsement Form. These documents collectively outline the issues at hand and the history of the case.

Timing and Procedure: The applicant must serve the trial record on the opposing party at least 30 days before the trial and then file it with the court. This ensures all parties have sufficient time to review the documents and prepare their arguments.

Updating Financial Statements: Reflecting Current Realities

The Role of Financial Statements: Financial statements play a critical role in trials involving support or property division, offering a detailed look at each party’s financial situation to inform decisions on support payments and asset division.

Rule 13 Compliance: It’s imperative to update your Financial Statement according to Rule 13, reflecting any changes in your financial circumstances since your last submission unless exempted by your Trial Scheduling Endorsement Form.

Inclusion in the Trial Record: Incorporating your updated Financial Statement into the trial record ensures the judge has access to current financial information, which is vital for making informed decisions.

Leveraging Offers to Settle: A Tool for Resolution and Cost Recovery

Strategic Advantages: Offers to settle can avert a trial and influence the court’s decision on legal costs. They demonstrate a willingness to compromise and can be perceived as reasonable by the court.

Crafting Your Offer: An effective offer to settle should be clear, specific, and realistic, taking into consideration the legal framework and the needs of both parties. It typically outlines proposed financial settlements, property divisions, or custody arrangements.

Impact on Costs: If the case goes to trial, any offers to settle may be considered by the judge when determining legal costs. A reasonable offer that was rejected by the other party could lead to a favorable cost order for the offeror under Rules 18 and 24.

Laying the Groundwork for Trial Success

Navigating through the pre-trial phase in family court requires meticulous preparation and a clear understanding of the legal processes involved. By compiling a comprehensive trial record, ensuring your financial statements are up to date, and thoughtfully crafting offers to settle, you set the stage for a more structured and potentially less contentious trial process. These preparatory steps not only help articulate your position clearly but also demonstrate your commitment to resolving the matter efficiently and fairly.

Stephanie Brooks, Associate Lawyer

Remember, the goal of this phase is not just to prepare for trial, but to potentially pave the way for settlement outside of court, saving time, costs, and emotional strain.

As we transition from understanding the foundational elements of trial preparation, our journey through the complexities of family court continues. The road ahead includes mastering the intricacies of presenting your case effectively at trial and navigating the post-trial landscape, including understanding and influencing the court’s decisions on costs.

Upcoming in Part 2: Mastering Your Trial

In the next installment of our series, we delve into the heart of the trial process. From selecting and preparing your witnesses to the strategic presentation of documents as evidence, we’ll explore how to effectively communicate your case to the judge. Additionally, we’ll cover essential courtroom etiquette, ensuring you make the best possible impression during your trial. This guide will equip you with the knowledge to confidently step into the courtroom, ready to present your case with poise and precision.

Preview of Part 3: The Trial Process and Beyond

The final article in our series will guide you through the trial process from start to finish, including opening statements, the examination of witnesses, and the crucial closing arguments. We’ll also provide insights into the judge’s decision-making process and the implications for both parties. Understanding the potential for costs and how they’re determined will be a key focus, helping you to navigate the financial aspects of your trial’s outcome. With a comprehensive view of the entire process, you’ll be better prepared to face the challenges and opportunities of your family law trial.

Stay tuned for these insightful guides designed to navigate the complexities of separation and divorce trials, providing clarity, and empowering you with the knowledge to approach your trial with confidence.

Stay in Touch

Keep learning about the latest issues in Ontario family law! Subscribe to our newsletter, have our latest articles delivered to your inbox, or listen to our Podcast Family Law Now.

Be sure to find out more about the "new normal", by visiting our Covid-19 and Divorce Information Centre.

About the author

Russell Alexander

Russell Alexander is the Founder & Senior Partner of Russell Alexander Collaborative Family Lawyers.