You bought the house. Your name is on title. Your parents provided the down payment.
So if the relationship ends, the house and the money must still be yours, right?
Not necessarily.
One of the more expensive mistakes people make is assuming that real estate ownership and family property rights are the same thing.
They are not.
In Ontario, the Family Law Act can dramatically change what happens to the value of a home when spouses separate. And for common-law couples, the absence of those statutory property-sharing rules can create an entirely different set of problems.
Here are five tips every Ontario homeowner and homebuyer should understand.
Tip #1: The Matrimonial Home Plays by Different Rules
Ontario family law gives the matrimonial home special treatment.
Normally, when married spouses separate, each calculates their net family property. As part of that calculation, a spouse can generally deduct the value of property they owned on the date of marriage.
But there is an important exception.
If a property that one spouse owned on the date of marriage is the matrimonial home at separation, its marriage-date value cannot generally be deducted.
Consider a simple example.
You buy a house before marriage for $500,000. By the time you marry, it is worth $700,000. You and your spouse continue living there, and it is worth $1 million when you separate.
You might assume that the $700,000 you brought into the marriage is protected and only the subsequent $300,000 increase matters.
That assumption can be very wrong.
Because the property is the matrimonial home, the normal marriage-date deduction does not apply.
The tip: If you already own a home and are planning to marry while continuing to live there together, get family law advice before the wedding. The fact that you bought the property years earlier does not give it the same treatment as other pre-marriage assets.
Tip #2: Be Very Careful With Gifts From Parents
The Bank of Mom and Dad has become a major part of the Ontario housing market.
It can also create significant family law problems.
Generally, a gift or inheritance received from a third party during marriage may qualify as excluded property if the statutory requirements are satisfied and the property can still be properly traced.
The matrimonial home is different.
Suppose your parents give you $200,000 during your marriage. You keep that money in a separate investment account and can trace it. Depending on the circumstances, you may be able to claim an exclusion.
Now suppose you take that same $200,000 and put it into the matrimonial home.
The result can be very different because the Family Law Act specifically treats the matrimonial home differently from other gifted or inherited property.
The fact that the mortgage company has a letter saying the money was a “gift” does not determine how the money will be treated between spouses if they later separate.
The tip: Before putting a significant gift or inheritance into the family home, talk to a family lawyer. Once the money goes into the house, it may be difficult or impossible to obtain the protection you assumed you had.
Tip #3: Common-Law Does Not Automatically Mean 50/50
This may be one of the most persistent myths in Ontario family law.
“We have lived together for years, so we’re basically married.”
Not when it comes to property division.
Ontario’s statutory equalization regime applies to married spouses. There is no equivalent automatic property-sharing regime simply because an unmarried couple has lived together for a particular number of years.
Imagine this situation.
A couple lives together for eight years. The house is registered solely in one partner’s name. The other partner contributes toward the mortgage, pays household expenses and puts substantial money and labour into renovations.
When they separate, the non-owner may expect half the house.
There is no automatic entitlement to it.
The non-titled partner may potentially have equitable claims, including unjust enrichment and constructive trust claims, depending on the facts. But proving those claims is very different from participating in the statutory equalization process available to married spouses.
It can also mean litigation.
The tip: If you are buying a home with someone you are not married to, decide what happens to the property before you buy it. A cohabitation agreement can be considerably cheaper than asking a court to reconstruct your financial relationship years later.
Tip #4: Being on Title Isn’t the Only Thing That Matters
The opposite misconception is:
“The house is in my name, so my partner can’t touch it.”
Again, not necessarily.
For married spouses, title alone does not determine the equalization consequences of the property.
For common-law partners, being off title does not necessarily mean there can never be a claim against the property or its value.
Courts can be asked to examine the parties’ contributions and the overall circumstances of their relationship when equitable claims such as unjust enrichment are advanced.
This is why two apparently similar couples can have very different outcomes.
One couple may have jointly purchased a house and carefully documented their respective interests.
Another may have put the property in one person’s name for mortgage purposes while both contributed substantial money to it for 15 years.
The deed may look simple. The family law case may not be.
The tip: Do not use title as a substitute for an agreement. If your real understanding about ownership is different from what appears on paper, document that understanding properly.
Tip #5: Have the Awkward Conversation Before Buying the House
People will spend weeks negotiating the price of a house, comparing mortgage rates and debating whether to spend another $30,000 on a kitchen.
Yet many couples never have a serious conversation about what their largest asset actually means financially.
Before buying property together, consider asking:
Who is providing the down payment?
Is that money a contribution, gift or loan?
Will we own the property equally?
Who will pay the mortgage?
What happens if one person pays for major renovations?
What happens if we marry?
What happens if we separate?
What happens if one person wants to sell and the other does not?
Those questions may not be romantic.
Neither is a three-year court case about a house.
The tip: Treat a marriage contract or cohabitation agreement as part of the financial planning surrounding a major real estate purchase, rather than something to discuss only after a relationship is already in difficulty.
Marriage Contracts Aren’t About Betting Against the Marriage
There is still a tendency to treat a marriage contract as though one person is planning the divorce before the wedding.
That gets it backwards.
If you marry without a marriage contract, you are not avoiding rules about separation.
You are accepting the rules the Ontario government has already created for you.
A marriage contract allows spouses, within the limits of the law, to make their own arrangements concerning issues such as ownership and division of property.
Similarly, unmarried couples can use a cohabitation agreement to establish their respective property rights and obligations instead of leaving those questions to be fought over after separation.
That is financial planning, not pessimism.
The Bottom Line
For most Ontario families, their home is their largest asset.
It deserves more planning than simply deciding whose name goes on the deed.
The matrimonial home receives unique treatment under Ontario family law. Gifts and inheritances can lose protections when put into it. Common-law partners do not receive the same automatic property-sharing rights as married spouses. And title alone may not answer every question about what happens when a relationship ends.
So before buying a home, getting married or putting a large family gift into real estate, ask one more question:
What happens to this money if our relationship ends?
It is much easier to answer that question while everyone is getting along than after they have separated.
