By Russell Alexander, Ontario Family Lawyer
In a case that reads like a Hollywood thriller, Ghost Adventures host Aaron Goodwin has filed for divorce after his wife, Victoria Goodwin, was accused of hiring a convicted killer to arrange his murder. This shocking and tragic case, playing out in Nevada, raises important legal and emotional issues for spouses facing the end of a marriage—especially in cases involving deception, danger, or criminal activity.
While most divorces in Ontario do not involve murder plots, this story underscores key legal principles that apply in any high-conflict or emotionally charged separation. Here’s what Ontario spouses can learn from this case when it comes to divorce, spousal misconduct, and protecting oneself legally and financially.
1. No-Fault Divorce vs. Misconduct: Can Criminal Behaviour Impact Divorce?
Ontario follows a no-fault divorce system, meaning that courts do not consider wrongdoing—such as infidelity or even criminal behaviour—when granting a divorce. Spouses only need to prove that their marriage has broken down, which is typically established by:
- One year of separation, or
- Adultery or cruelty, though these grounds are rarely used because they require proof.
In Goodwin’s case, the betrayal and alleged criminal plot are clear indicators that the marriage is over. However, even in Ontario, a judge would not necessarily take such behaviour into account when deciding whether a divorce should be granted.
2. Division of Property: Can a Spouse Lose Their Rights Due to Criminal Behaviour?
One key issue in this case is how the couple’s assets will be divided. In Ontario, the equalization of net family property ensures that both spouses share in the financial growth of the marriage, regardless of misconduct. This means that even a spouse accused of serious wrongdoing—such as fraud, infidelity, or even attempted murder—may still be entitled to a share of the family’s property.
That said, Ontario law does allow for an unequal division of property in rare cases where it would be “unconscionable” to divide assets equally. While the bar for unconscionability is high, a judge might consider extreme misconduct—like attempting to have a spouse killed—as a factor in adjusting property division.
3. Exclusive Possession of the Home: Protecting Yourself in a High-Risk Separation
Goodwin has petitioned the court to keep a separate residence from his estranged wife. In Ontario, spouses in dangerous or high-conflict situations can also apply for exclusive possession of the matrimonial home. This means:
- One spouse is granted the legal right to stay in the home, even if the property is jointly owned.
- The other spouse can be ordered to leave, particularly if there is a risk of harm.
- The decision is based on factors such as the best interests of children, domestic violence concerns, and financial circumstances.
If a spouse is facing threats, harassment, or criminal behaviour from their partner, seeking a restraining order alongside exclusive possession may be necessary.
4. Restraining Orders and Emergency Protections
Goodwin has obtained a court order requiring Victoria to stay away from him for three months. In Ontario, a spouse facing threats can apply for a restraining order under the Family Law Act if they fear for their safety.
- A restraining order prohibits an ex-spouse from contacting or coming near the applicant.
- It can be customized to include workplace, home, or even digital communication restrictions.
- Breaching a restraining order is a criminal offence.
If a situation involves immediate danger, the police can intervene, and an emergency protection order can be sought
5. When Divorce Isn’t Enough: Ending a Marriage Safely
One of the most chilling aspects of this case is that Victoria allegedly told an associate: “I chose to end his existence. Not divorce.”
For anyone contemplating divorce, this reinforces an important truth: If you are unhappy in your marriage, divorce is always a legal and safe option—hiring a hitman is not.
In Ontario, separating from a spouse is a straightforward legal process. If one spouse does not agree to divorce, the other can still file on the grounds of one year of separation. While emotional conflict and financial disputes can make separation difficult, legal options exist to ensure safety, fairness, and a fresh start.
Final Thoughts: Lessons for Ontario Spouses
While Goodwin’s case is extreme, it highlights key issues that many separating spouses face, including the importance of legal protections, fair asset division, and ensuring personal safety. If you are considering separation or divorce, consulting a family lawyer can help you understand your rights and navigate the process without unnecessary risk or conflict.
At Russell Alexander Collaborative Family Lawyers, we help Ontario families resolve divorce matters efficiently and fairly—without the need for courtroom drama (or criminal charges). If you need guidance on divorce, property division, or personal protection orders, contact our team today.
